Press J to jump to the feed. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts
Collection byu/RSurvivorMods·9 posts
Season 38 Castaway Assessments
Edge of Extinction Castaway Assessments | Joe Anglim & Aubry Bracco
Edge of Extinction Castaway Assessments | Victoria Baamonde & Ron Clark
Edge of Extinction Castaway Assessments | Julia Carter & Eric Hafemann
Edge of Extinction Castaway Assessments | Aurora McCreary & Julie Rosenberg
Edge of Extinction Castaway Assessments | Gavin Whitson & Dan "The Wardog" DaSilva
Edge of Extinction Castaway Assessments | Reem Daly & Rick Devens
Edge of Extinction Castaway Assessments | Wendy Diaz & Lauren O'Connell
Edge of Extinction Castaway Assessments | Kelly Wentworth & David Wright
Edge of Extinction Castaway Assessments | Keith Sowell & Chris Underwood
Posted by
Pirates Steal
2 months ago
Moderator of r/survivor

Edge of Extinction Castaway Assessments | Julia Carter & Eric Hafemann

In anticipation of the premiere of Survivor: Edge of Extinction we will be making a stickied post over the next nine days to discuss two contestants a day. These threads will provide a resource for everyone to get to know the contestants better before seeing them on our televisions.

Please give your opinions, predictions, impressions or whatever else you’d like to share about Julia and Eric in this thread. We will save it as a ‘time capsule’ and link back after they are eliminated (or named Sole Survivor) to see how opinions have changed.

Julia Carter

Age: 24

Hometown: Hazleton, Pennsylvania

Current residence: Bethesda, MD

Occupation: Medical Assistant

Tribe: Kama

CBS Bio | Twitter Video

Eric Hafemann

Age: 34

Hometown: Chicago

Current residence: Livermore, California

Occupation: Firefighter

Tribe: Kama

CBS Bio | Twitter Video

You can check out the other contestants in our Castaway Assessments Hub

95% Upvoted
What are your thoughts? Log in or Sign uplog insign up
level 1
23 points · 2 months ago

Julia seems social/likable enough to get along with everybody and smart enough to have a good pulse on the game. Could be a sleeper pick as I think she'll be able to stay out of trouble and under the radar fairly easily.

Eric is definitely a contender. Firefighter dad is a combo that worked for Jeremy (good luck finding people that'll want to take you to the end though). He gave a really great answer in his bio about not taking himself too seriously and showing humility, which is an attitude that will definitely help him in the game.

level 1

in the post Game Changers seasons (HHH GI DvG) there have been a small handful of really memorable players who dominated the game, the edit, and screen time, for example, Chrissy, Ben, Joe Mena, Dom, Wendell, Michael, Christian, Angelina, Gabby, etc, and I really feel like Julia is going to be that type of player/character this season. She is clearly a very well educated young woman, has depth, and seems to have some strategic chops. Very excited for her, a potential survivor legend in the making.

level 1
8 points · 2 months ago

They both have great personal / family stories to tell to the jury if they get to the end.

They also start on what I think will be the stronger tribe - I could even see them working together.

But I have to question Eric's Survivor knowledge. I mean, how can you not have a favorite season? He mentions Tony in the bio and Woo in another interview, so was it that hard to say Cagayan? I don't think he will be strategic at all - but he may be a useful vote on a majority alliance.

I think they will both be jurors.

level 1
Jeff Probst King of Sass
8 points · 2 months ago

Watching Eric’s assessment videos, he really confuses me. I see him making it far, but I feel he’ll get a JP edit. Julia on the other hand, I have put as a contender to win. She’s seems intelligent, social, and will assimilate well into her tribe. I like her and do see her making it far and/or making it to Final Tribal Council.

level 1
7 points · 2 months ago

I'm so unsure of if I want Julia as my winner pick. She seems super savvy, and I usually pick the most "average" cast members, and she fits the bill to me. Her story that she told in her cast videos and talking about how she doesn't know why she is here though sort of worries me.

Eric arguably could do well if he actually has a strategy, but all we get from him is doofiness. I wouldn't be shocked if he were purpled, or made it deep.

level 1
5 points · 2 months ago

I'm really high on Julia. She has a great pulse on the game coupled with a very friendly demeanor. I could see her being someone who flies under the radar for quite some time (whilst giving us some great confessionals because she is so articulate) and then makes a big splash post merge. She also has a great story to light her fire throughout the game - take a look at her website. If she could link up with another power-player in the game she could do some great things. She touched upon her philosophy on the game in her FOO interview, and in my opinion her immense preparation will help her make some excellent strides through and through.

Eric gives me mixed feelings. On one hand I appreciate his light-hearted demeanor while also coming across as a physical threat; on the other hand I worry he will come across as too nonchalant about many components of the game. In FOO he was very humble about what he has in life and doesn't seem too concerned about winning, which could hurt his passion in the long run. He's quiet for sure, and could come across as a "silent but deadly" type.

level 1
5 points · 2 months ago

I’m almost certain that Julia will make the merge, I don’t see any reason she would go out earlier than that. She’s my winner pick for now, but this is admittedly because I feel she meets similar qualities to Danni and Sophie (young newbie female with the likability of Danni and the intellect of Sophie), winners of two of our other captains seasons. I’m putting my bets on Julia.

level 1
9 points · 2 months ago

Eric is confusing. On paper, he probably should be a front runner to be a very popular winner pick (his group he's in age wise & background wise have done very well in the 30's stretch of seasons) but I'm not really getting promising vibes at all. It's mainly the videos he's in, to me he seems very out of his element in all that I've seen. I don't know I'm not expecting much of him & don't have high expectations. So I guess I could be pleasantly surprised, but not holding my breath for it.

Julia hits me as kind of a Michele/Sierra/Chelsea/Ashley type of player. Somebody who might have a bit of a rough footing early on, but likely has the ability to make it decently deep as long as they can find an alliance that sees worth in having her around for the long run. I might question whether she's aggressive enough to actually play hard when push comes to shove, but Julia probably is the female newbie I feel the most confident about likely making the merge without much trouble (as long as she groups up with the right people like said above)

level 1
3 points · 2 months ago

These are the two people I’m deciding between with my winner pick and it’s neck and neck. Eric to me just has that Survivor winner look and he’s super chill. Julia seems really smart and has the drive and desire to do well. I think I might just flip a coin at this point. 😅

level 1
4 points · 2 months ago

I'm not seeing what everybody else is in Julia, she seems forgettable and boring to me. I was pretty high on Eric from his bio but he seems very subdued in his interviews so he could go either way

level 1
2 points · 2 months ago

I like Julia, but I'm not sure I feel like she has the killer instinct to win and that might make her more of a passive player. But even with that being said, looking at the cast I think she's one of the better females on the season in terms of knowing the game and actually having a chance to make it far.

If I had to pick a male winner, Eric would be either #1 or 2 for me. Seems sociable, charming, he fits that alpha male mid-30s family man that always seems to do well on Survivor. Only red flag for me is that he's playing with 4 very smart returning players who I think will be more threatened by him than charmed.

level 1

Julia is such a standout amongst the newbies that I'm hesitant to actually think she can get to the end even with the returnees. She could play a fantastic game and get cut right before the final 4 or she could be a victim of someone's else's big move, but it's hard to see her making it all the way barring a god tier social game. If she can somehow get to the end, I think she'll be a top 10 winner, but I'm thinking a post merge exit and wouldn't completely rule out a shock late pre merge boot if someone wants to pull a Jay on a swapped tribe.

I don't think Eric would have that much chance on a season like DvG, but given what we know about this season, I wouldn't completely rule him out. If he plays to his strengths and uses his social game, and is able to keep the target off him and on the returnees and more strategic newbies, it's possible he could get to the end. But is he savvy enough to pull this off?

level 1
0 points · 2 months ago · edited 2 months ago

Eric will be the first eliminated contestant to win the game. He seems not greatly suited for the game but very well suited to charm on EOE and win back in.

level 1

Eric could be someone who wins or goes deep but he could be targeted in merge for being well liked and strong. For Julia I think she could go deep to as she’s smart and strong but could see her going earlier as well for being openly smart

level 1
1 point · 2 months ago

I can see Eric getting Brendan Shapiro'd but with EoE in play, I think he has the best chance of getting back in the game (even more than Joe). He'll definitely be a leader type who will either get along with the returnees or the returnees will view him as a threat and take him out early.

Julia is so likeable. I feel like she's gonna be under the radar in the game and the castaways wont see her until she's deep into the merge. Might be too late to take her out by then.

level 1
1 point · 2 months ago

Eric is very likeable in an understated way and i see him fitting in really well with his tribe. He runs the risk of becoming a target post-merge but I think he may have the ability to slide enough under the radar that other threats get taken out before him. He understands the game pretty well and he has a shot of getting to the end. He could win.

level 1
1 point · 2 months ago

I can't imagine anybody disliking Julia. Socially she's probably going to be able to build good relationships early and I see her getting into an alliance. I'm not sure if she's ruthless enough for this game though and I could see her getting blindsided by other contestants that are just more cutthroat.

level 1
-1 points · 2 months ago

Julia seems genuinely keen to be out there on the island rather than the fake "OMG I'm so grateful" posturing you get from a lot of contestants. Her story seems to be a bit of a worry moving forward because it's dangerously teetering on the edge of being in lieu of her personality as a castaway which is unfortunate because she is one of the most genuine people out there. I like her quite a lot, she'll find her place and go deep.

Eric... Well, Eric is the textbook F grade for casting. He is nothing more than a dad with muscles. His presence is beneficial to his tribe being the stacked one. When mentioning firefighter winners he only mentions Jeremy Collins and not Tom Westman which annoys me more than it probably should but there you go. Likely he will carry his tribe premerge and then get bitten postmerge. I'd rate him to do well on the island twist but in the case of such a bland filler contestant as him, that's a detriment to the season. Can't even love to hate the guy, he's just bland filler. Out of everyone he's probably the worst winner the show could get. Yes worse than Joe who this season is mostly built from the ground up for. Thank u, next

level 2
1 point · 2 months ago

Apparently we're not allowed to have that opinion. Oops. Oh well.

level 1
-4 points · 2 months ago · edited 2 months ago

Eric: The golden boy is my least favorite archetype and we already have Joe. Eric humble brags incessantly in his ET Canada interview. "I'm not a hero. Oh no. No one who saves lives everyday would truly consider themselves a hero. It's all in a day's work. I'm just a regular guy who rescues kittens from trees and hands lost children back to their grateful mothers." Personally, I also don't have shredded abs or an All-American family and I'm not an outspoken Christian. I'm a barnacle on society. We have nothing in common.

Julia: I like Julia as a person and I'd totally be her friend, but I'm not sure I'll like her as a Survivor character. Maybe it's because she reminds me of a proto Desiree Williams - brilliant professional, glowing beauty queen, smart observer of Survivor, black female role model, totally disappointing TV character. With 18 big personalities, and the 4 returnees expected to grab 75% of the air time, I just don't foresee Julia sticking her neck out far enough to be seen. And when it comes to Survivor, purple is a drab color. But, I hope to be wrong.


70.9k castaways1.5k passengers at Tribal Council
Information and discussion about the greatest show in television history: Survivor!
Top Posts From The r/survivor Community
Continue browsing in r/survivor
Community Details




passengers at Tribal Council

Information and discussion about the greatest show in television history: Survivor!

Redesign Info


If you're reading this, you are using the reddit redesign. As the redesign is incomplete and lacks many tools used by /r/Survivor, we recommend using "Old Reddit."

You can use Old Reddit by using OR by opting out completely. You can see instructions for how to opt out here.

If you have any feedback about /r/Survivor's redesign, please message the moderators. However, please keep in mind that many aspects of the redesign are out of our hands for the time being.

You can read more information about /r/Survivor and the redesign here.

User Flair

The user flair system is currently incomplete on the redesign. Therefore, users must request flairs on the old site. The text of the flair will display on the redesign, but gold/silver/winner flairs and winner badges will NOT show up on the redesign for the time being.

You can choose a flair on this page.


You can access the Reddit Survivor Discord here.

/r/Survivor and the Reddit Survivor Discord have a loose affiliation. While they are connected as partner platforms, they are moderated differently by overall different groups of mods. However, vote manipulation on /r/Survivor, promoted from Discord, will not be tolerated. Same with harassment that crosses channels, either way — this too will be dealt with by warnings and bans.

r/survivor Rules
Be civil to other users
Keep post titles free of episode spoilers before Friday
No spoilers other than cast/theme/location
Edgic posts and comments should be properly tagged
"Fluff" posts should be properly flaired
No speculation or predictions based on spoilers
No overly sexualizing contestants
No BrantSteele
No repetitive memes
Subreddit Calendar

S38 Episode 11

April 25, 2019 • 0:00
S38E11: La Cheeserie! Synopsis:

S38 Episode 12

May 2, 2019 • 0:00
S38E12: Synopsis:

S38 Episode 13

May 9, 2019 • 0:00
S38E13: Synopsis:

S38 Finale

May 16, 2019 • 0:00
S38E14: Synopsis:
Discussion Archives

These archives contain episode discussions and other weekly threads for past seasons of Survivor

Survivor Communities

3.6k members


1.7k members


2.0k members


333 members


1.2k members


146 members

Reality Competition Shows

10.1k members


87.9k members


27.2k members


246k members

The Wardog
Oh, in the sand?
Robotics Expert
Offical flair bot of /r/Survivor.
Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.